Side-by-Side Comparison

TradeDayvsLucid Trading

See how TradeDay and Lucid Trading compare on profit split, challenge fee, drawdown rules, payout frequency, and verified trader ratings — all in one place.

VS
TradeDay prop firm logo

TradeDay

3.7

3

3.7 rated5 day minNinjaTrader
View Challenges
Logo

Lucid Trading

5.0

9

5.0 rated2 day minNinjaTrader
View Challenges
VS

Profit Split

80%vs90%
TradeDay prop firm logo
Logo

Max Allocation

$450Kvs$750K
TradeDay prop firm logo
Logo

Challenge fee (50K, 1-step)

$62.5vs$84
TradeDay prop firm logo
Logo

Trader Satisfaction

3.7vs5.0
TradeDay prop firm logo
Logo

Head-to-head Breakdown

TradeDay prop firm logo

TradeDay

Logo

Lucid Trading

Program name

TradeDay - QuickPay Intraday - 1-Step - 50K
Lucid Trading - LucidFlex 1-Step - 50K-TEST

Profit split

80%
90%best

Max allocation

$450K
$750Kbest

Challenge fee (50K, 1-step)

$125best
$140

Discounted challenge fee

$62.5best
$84

Profit target

No Requirement
No Requirement

Daily Loss Limit

No Requirement
No Requirement

Daily Loss Type

No Requirement
No Requirement

Max Loss Limit

4%
4%

Max Loss Type

Trailing
Trailing

Consistency rule

Profits during one single trading day should not exceed 30% of the profit target.
- Evaluation stage: 50% - Funded stage: None

Min trading days

5 days
2 daysbest

Payout frequency

Every 1 daysbest
Every 5 days

Platforms

NinjaTrader, TradingView, Jigsaw Daytradr, Tradovate, TradeDayX
NinjaTrader, Bookmap, Sierra Chart, MotiveWave, TradingView, Tradesea, Jigsaw Daytradr, MultiCharts, Quantower, R Trader Pro, Tradovate, ATAS Orderflow Trading

News trading

Restricted
Allowedbest

EA / algo trading

Allowed
Allowed

Scaling plan

Yes
Yes

Earnings Calculator

Estimate your monthly take-home based on account size and expected monthly return.

TradeDay prop firm logo
TradeDay
Account Size$50K
Monthly return (%)8%

Monthly earnings

$3.2K

80% of $4K gross profit

Monthly Earnings
80% payout
Logo
Lucid Trading
Account Size$50K
Monthly return (%)8%

Monthly earnings

$3.6K

90% of $4K gross profit

Monthly Earnings
90% payout+ $400 advantage

Compare Firms

The headline difference is profit split — Lucid Trading offers 90% while TradeDay offers 80%. Beyond that, Lucid Trading charges $140 with a max allocation of $750,000, compared to TradeDay's $125 and $450,000.

TradeDay's challenge fee of $125 is lower than Lucid Trading's $140, making it the lower-cost option for traders focused on upfront fees.

Lucid Trading offers a 90% profit split, compared with TradeDay's 80%. The 10 percentage point difference can become meaningful as trading profits increase.

Lucid Trading offers a maximum allocation of $750,000, compared with TradeDay's $450,000. Traders looking to manage larger amounts of capital may prefer Lucid Trading.

Both firms use a 1-step evaluation. Lucid Trading requires 2 minimum trading days per phase, while TradeDay requires 5. Lucid Trading provides greater scheduling flexibility.

Drawdown information is unavailable for both Lucid Trading and TradeDay.

Lucid Trading pays out every 5 days, while TradeDay pays out every 1 days.

TradeDay offers more frequent access to profits, which may appeal to traders who prioritize regular cash flow.

Both Lucid Trading and TradeDay offer a scaling plan, allowing funded traders to increase their account allocation over time by meeting performance targets.

Lucid Trading leads on both rating (5) and review volume (9), making it the stronger customer satisfaction signal. TradeDay has a 3.7 rating from 3 reviews.

Help Center

Stay Connected

Subscribe For The Latest In Prop Trading News And Deals

200 Loyalty Points Welcome Bonus.

Sign up free to claim points, unlock rewards, save favorite firms, and start earning more through reviews and platform activity.

Create Free Account
Prop Firm Business

Have Questions?

Contact Us for More.

Contact Us
twitter-logoinstagram-logoyoutube-logotiktok-logolinkedin-logo

© 2026 Prop Firm Match. All rights reserved.