Side-by-Side Comparison

TradeDayvsQA Test Firm

See how TradeDay and QA Test Firm compare on profit split, challenge fee, drawdown rules, payout frequency, and verified trader ratings — all in one place.

VS
TradeDay prop firm logo

TradeDay

3.7

3

3.7 rated5 day minNinjaTrader
View Challenges
QA

QA Test Firm

4.0

1

4.0 ratedMT4
View Challenges
VS

Profit Split

80%vsNo Requirement
TradeDay prop firm logo
QA

Max Allocation

$450KvsNo Requirement
TradeDay prop firm logo
QA

Challenge fee (50K, 1-step)

$62.5vsNo Requirement
TradeDay prop firm logo
QA

Trader Satisfaction

3.7vs4.0
TradeDay prop firm logo
QA

Head-to-head Breakdown

TradeDay prop firm logo

TradeDay

QA

QA Test Firm

Program name

TradeDay - QuickPay Intraday - 1-Step - 50K
No Requirement

Profit split

80%
No Requirement

Max allocation

$450K
No Requirement

Challenge fee (50K, 1-step)

$125
No Requirement

Discounted challenge fee

$62.5
No Requirement

Profit target

No Requirement
No Requirement

Daily Loss Limit

No Requirement
No Requirement

Daily Loss Type

No Requirement
No Requirement

Max Loss Limit

4%
No Requirement

Max Loss Type

Trailing
No Requirement

Consistency rule

Profits during one single trading day should not exceed 30% of the profit target.
None

Min trading days

5 days
No Requirement

Payout frequency

Every 1 days
No Requirement

Platforms

NinjaTrader, TradingView, Jigsaw Daytradr, Tradovate, TradeDayX
MT4

News trading

Restricted
No Requirement

EA / algo trading

Allowed
No Requirement

Scaling plan

Yes
No

Earnings Calculator

Estimate your monthly take-home based on account size and expected monthly return.

TradeDay prop firm logo
TradeDay
Account Size$50K
Monthly return (%)8%

Monthly earnings

$3.2K

80% of $4K gross profit

Monthly Earnings
80% payout
QA
QA Test Firm
Account Size$50K
Monthly return (%)8%

No data available

QA Test Firm might not offer $50K accounts

Monthly Earnings
No Requirement

Compare Firms

Challenge information for QA Test Firm is currently unavailable, so a direct comparison isn't possible. TradeDay offers a 80% profit split, charges $125, funds up to $450,000, and uses a 1-step evaluation.

TradeDay charges $125 per challenge. Challenge information for QA Test Firm is currently unavailable, so a direct comparison can't be made.

TradeDay offers a 80% profit split. Challenge information for QA Test Firm is currently unavailable, so a direct comparison can't be made.

TradeDay offers a maximum allocation of $450,000. Maximum allocation information for QA Test Firm is currently unavailable, so a direct comparison can't be made.

Challenge details for QA Test Firm are currently unavailable, so the evaluation process can't be compared directly. TradeDay uses a 1-step evaluation with a minimum of 5 trading days per phase.

Challenge details for QA Test Firm are unavailable, and TradeDay doesn't currently publish its drawdown type.

TradeDay pays out every 1 days. Challenge information for QA Test Firm is currently unavailable, so a direct comparison can't be made.

TradeDay offers a scaling plan that allows successful traders to increase their allocation over time. Challenge information for QA Test Firm is currently unavailable, so a direct comparison can't be made.

QA Test Firm holds a 4 rating from 1 reviews, while TradeDay holds a 3.7 rating from 3 reviews. QA Test Firm scores higher, but TradeDay's rating is based on a larger sample size, so both factors are worth considering.

Help Center

Stay Connected

Subscribe For The Latest In Prop Trading News And Deals